The Stefacado
House-made avocado spread, tomato, pickled onions and micro-cilantro on toasted multigrain bread; 2 eggs your style.
$12.49
Cafe 51 Menus
Browse our menus any time. Breakfast is dine-in or take out only. Lunch and dinner pickup and delivery may be ordered through Toast during available ordering hours.
Breakfast
Tuesday–Saturday, 7:00–11:00 AM. Dine-in or takeout only; not available for online ordering or delivery.
Main Street
Biscuit and Gravy
Buttermilk biscuit with house-made sausage gravy, 2 eggs your style, and tomato, gouda grits, potatoes or fruit medley.
$12.49
Chicken & Waffle
One waffle with 3 fried chicken strips, powdered sugar and house-made hot honey on the side.
$14.95
Egg Combo
2 eggs, 2 pancakes and 2 strips of bacon or 2 sausage patties. Add chocolate chips +$2.05.
$13.24
Egg Plate
2 eggs, 2 sausage patties or 2 strips bacon; tomato, gouda grits, potatoes or fruit medley; multigrain or sourdough toast.
$12.49
Egg Sandwich
2 eggs over hard on grilled sourdough with cheddar, American cheese and bacon or sausage; choice of tomato, gouda grits, potatoes or fruit medley.
$13.95
Our Mama’s Pancakes
3 pancakes with bacon or sausage. Add chocolate chips +$2.75.
$10.99
Steak & Eggs
Ribeye steak cooked medium well, 2 eggs your style, tomato, gouda grits, potatoes or fruit medley, and multigrain or sourdough toast.
$22.99
Tina’s Morning JamBurger
Never-frozen burger patty, choice of cheese, bacon jam, one egg your style, and tomato, gouda grits, potatoes or fruit medley.
$15.99
Waffle Plate
One waffle with bacon or sausage.
$12.49
The Wannabe Italian
Pounded, breaded and fried pork cutlet with sausage gravy, 2 eggs your style, tomato, gouda grits, potatoes or fruit medley, and multigrain or sourdough toast.
$16.49
Side Street
Side items that may be added to any order.
Gouda grits
$5.29
Tomato
$2.99
Potatoes
$4.49
Biscuit
$3.49
Sourdough toast (2)
$4.49
Multigrain toast (2)
$4.49
Sausage
$5.29
Bacon
$5.49
Fruit medley
$3.99
Egg (each)
$2.29
Sausage gravy
$3.99
Subway
Substitutions only for the items listed.
Biscuit instead of toast with a Main Street item
$1.50
Fries, sweet fries or onion rings instead of an included Main Street side
$2.50
Playground
Kids’ Breakfast — Under 10 years old.
Chocolate Chip Pancake
One chocolate chip pancake with one strip of bacon or one sausage patty.
$7.99
Scrambled Egg
Scrambled eggs with one strip of bacon or one sausage patty.
$6.49
Chicken Strips
2 fried chicken strips with regular or sweet fries.
$7.99
Pancake Breakfast
One pancake with one strip of bacon or one sausage patty.
$5.99
Breakfast Drinks
Coke products, lemonade or iced tea
Add a flavor +$0.75 (flavor charged on refills).
$3.49
Coffee or hot tea
$3.49
Orange juice
$4.49
Kids’ OJ or soft drink (with meal)
$1.99
Lunch & Dinner
Tuesday–Thursday, 11:30 AM–8:00 PM; Friday–Saturday, 11:30 AM–8:30 PM.
Our Signature Items
We blend our own Segreto Cheese, Signature 51 Salad Dressing, and Steak Sauce.
Apps
Toasted Ravioli
Golden, crispy St. Louis-style ravioli generously dusted with parmesan and served with Tom’s red sauce perfect for dipping. (A St. Louis Thing)
$9.95
Cheese Garlic Bread
Toasted French bread with garlic, smothered in our signature Segreto 51 cheese blend and Italian spices, served with warm marinara. (A St. Louis Thing)
$9.95
Onion Rings
Onion rings fried to a crispy golden brown served with Southwest Ranch.
$11.95
Tenderloin Tips
Melt-in-your-mouth steak tips grilled to order and paired with our handcrafted Café 51 steak sauce.
$16.95
Ricotta-Zucchini Blossoms
Ricotta-filled zucchini blossoms are lightly breaded, flash fried and served with Tom’s red sauce.
$13.95
Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded and fried mozzarella sticks served with Tom’s house-made red sauce.
$10.95
Burgers
All burgers come with your choice of one side. Our burgers are made with premium beef.
Lakeland Burger
A juicy beef patty layered with cheddar, smoky bacon, crispy onion straws, and a drizzle of tangy BBQ sauce on a toasted bun.
$16.95
Smash Burger
Two smashed beef patties seared for crispy edges and juicy centers, served on a toasted bun.
Add cheese for 1.00
$15.49
Half Pound Burger
BYOB - Half pound beef patty seasoned and served on a toasted bun.
Add cheese for 1.00
$15.49
Salads & Soups
Café 51 House Salad
Mixed greens dressed in our signature Café 51 Italian dressing and Segreto 51 cheese blend, topped with red onion and cherry tomatoes.
$12.95
Caesar Salad
Classic Caesar with crisp romaine, parmesan cheese, and crunchy croutons. Add grilled or fried chicken breast for extra protein and flavor -
$12.95
Garden Salad
Mixed greens topped with mozzarella cheese, red onion, tomatoes, and crispy croutons with your choice of dressing.
$12.95
Georgia Peach Salad
Fire roasted peaches, mixed greens, Segreto cheese, cheddar cheese, grilled chicken, candied walnuts, and bacon, topped with house made hot honey and a drizzle of house made ranch dressing.
$18.95
Side Garden Salad
$4.99
Side 51 Salad
$5.99
Side Caesar Salad
$5.99
Protein options are not available for side salads.
Chili
$5.99
Soup of the Day
$5.99
Large Salad Add-ons
For large salads only: salmon $10.00; grilled/fried chicken $4.00; charbroiled chicken $5.00.
Wraps
All wraps come with one side. (Some sides are added cost.)
Southwest Chicken Wrap
A flour tortilla loaded with lettuce, tomato, shredded cheddar cheese, black bean salsa, blackened chicken, and Southwest dressing.
$15.49
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
A hearty wrap featuring crispy fried chicken, bleu cheese crumbles, shredded cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, ranch and house made Buffalo sauce in a soft flour tortilla.
$15.49
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled or fried chicken with romaine, shredded parmesan, and creamy Caesar dressing wrapped in a flour tortilla.
$14.95
Sandwiches
All sandwiches come with one included side, all others are added cost.
Grilled Cheese Melt
Cheddar, Provolone and American cheeses melted together with tomato and bacon on grilled sourdough.
$15.49
Chicken Club
Your choice of grilled or fried chicken with crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, smoky bacon, and your preferred cheese on a toasted bun.
$15.95
Turkey Club
Grilled turkey on grilled multigrain bread with lettuce, tomato, bacon, Swiss cheese and Tom’s avocado spread.
$17.49
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Hand-breaded chicken tossed in fiery Buffalo sauce, topped with Provolone cheese, fresh lettuce, and tomato on a toasted bun.
$14.95
Turkey Melt
Tender roasted turkey with Swiss cheese, tomato, and bacon finished with cool ranch on toasted sourdough.
$15.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grilled chicken, crispy bacon, and cool creamy ranch with warm Segreto 51 cheese on a garlic hoagie.
$15.95
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast served with lettuce and tomato on a toasted bun.
$14.49
Cafe 51 Twisted Plates
(Some sides are added cost.)
Nancy’s Bacon Noodles
Sautéed bacon, onion and garlic poured over Tom’s red sauced noodles (Our Mom’s Specialty) and served with a side salad.
$18.95
Prime Dip Sandwich
Slow roasted prime rib with Segreto 51 cheese on toasted garlic French bread, served with au jus and one side.
$19.49
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Hand breaded and deep fried, served with pickle, onion, and mayo on a toasted bun and served with one side. (A Saint Louis Thing).
$16.49
Café 51 Salad
Mixed greens dressed in our signature Café 51 Italian dressing and Segreto 51 cheese blend, topped with red onion, cherry tomatoes, and marinated lightly breaded chicken breast.
$17.95
Entrees
Charbroiled Chicken
Our signature dish featuring marinated chicken breast lightly breaded, charbroiled, served on a skewer. Served with one side salad and one side.
$23.95
Chicken a-la Kathy
Two grilled chicken breasts topped with Segreto cheese and a drizzle of butter, served with a side salad and one side.
$23.95
Salmon
Salmon grilled or blackened served with two sides.
$25.95
Chicken Strip Platter
Hand-breaded golden brown seasoned chicken strips served with fries or chips, coleslaw and your choice of dipping sauce.
$17.95
Chili Mac
Comfort food at its best: pasta smothered in hearty homemade chili, topped with shredded cheddar cheese, onions, sour cream, and scallions. (A St. Louis Thing)
$16.95
Tenderloin Tips
Tender charbroiled steak tips served with two sides (some sides are added cost), and house made steak sauce.
$24.95
Sides
Substitute a side salad, soup, or pasta for any side for 2.00.
House-made Potato Chips
$3.99
French Fries
$4.99
Onion Rings
Onion rings fried to a crispy golden brown served with Southwest Ranch.
$4.99
Sweet Potato Fries
$4.99
Vegetable of the Day
$3.99
Cole Slaw
$3.99
Mashed Potatoes
$3.99
Pasta with Tom’s Red Sauce
$5.99
Drinks
Coke products, lemonade and iced tea
Add a flavor +$0.75 (refills charged for flavoring).
$3.49
Hot coffee
$3.25
Beer, Wine, Sangria & Carbliss
Alcoholic beverages are available for on-premises consumption only. No alcoholic beverages are available for takeout, pickup, delivery or online ordering.
Beer
Michelob Ultra
$6.00
Miller Lite
$6.00
Modelo
$7.00
IPA
$7.00
Yuengling
$6.00
Heineken 0.0
$6.00
Wine
Glass and bottle prices are indicated where offered.
Prosecco
Glass $11.00
Kendall Jackson Chardonnay
Glass $10.00 · Bottle $38.00
Kim Crawford Pinot Grigio
Glass $10.00 · Bottle $38.00
Silvergate Pinot Grigio
Glass $8.00 · Bottle $26.00
Silvergate Moscato
Glass $8.00 · Bottle $26.00
Bonanza Cabernet Sauvignon
Glass $11.00 · Bottle $38.00
Silvergate Cabernet Sauvignon
Glass $8.00 · Bottle $26.00
Silvergate Merlot
Glass $8.00 · Bottle $26.00
Quilt
Bottle $55.00
Sangria
House Red Sangria
$10.00
House White Sangria
$10.00
Add flavors to sangria: $0.75 per glass.
Carbliss & Mimosas
Carbliss Flavored Vodka Drink
Ask your server about flavors.
$8.00
Mimosas
$5.00
Ask your server about gluten-free options.
Consumer advisory: Undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.